Category Archives: Politics

Clarion Poll shows tight race in Democratic Primary

With New York State voters set to go to the polls Tuesday, Hillary Clinton held a slight lead over Barack Obama among Democrats responding to the Clarion News Blog Presidential Poll, 5o% to 35%. However the two candidates were tied among all voters, each earning about 23% each.

The online poll was answered by 20 Democrats, 20 Republicans and 8 who were not registered with a major party. 75 per cent of the respondents were Geneseo residents with another 12 per cent residents of other Livingston County towns. Most of the responses were received before the South Carolina Democratic primary. It does not necessarily reflect a scientific sample of opinion.

John McCain held a commanding lead among Republicans, favored by 55%, with Rudy Guliani and Mitt Romney well back at 15 % each. Against the entire field, McCain was favored by 17% of the respondents.

Those who preferred Clinton cited the following reasons: Experienced in health care, Life and public experience, Intelligence, Experience with public office and integrity, Forthright, Hillary’s focused, gets things done and is practical, Intellectual capacity and that she is a strong, smart woman.

Those who preferred Obama cited his Intelligence, Honest, quick thinking, calm under pressure, Forward looking, fresh ideas, Non-connection with status quo; promise of change and outstanding character.

Those preferring McCain cited: Integrity honesty and experience, Logic, reason, and honesty, Honesty, war service and experience, Honesty,
Government experience both here & internationally, Honest, Connection to government – could get things done, and Experience, has faced adversity.

Complete results can be seen here. Thanks to all who participated!

A quick note on poll technique –and some early results!

I originally posted a link to the Clarion Presidential Poll directly from the home page, but after receiving some comments on the fairness of the poll, I decided to move the link here to a blog page so that people can post public comments. A number of Democrats seemed to think the poll is somehow slanted against their candidates.

The main complaint seems to be that I asked the match-up question by asking how people would vote if Clinton or Obama were the Democratic nominees. I did this merely for simplicity sake, since the Democratic race seems to be coming down to a two-way contest.

I could, of course, have done individual match-up questions for all the possible permutations of candidates, but the poll would have ended up with 100 questions instead of 10. I’m not sure I will convince partisan Democrats that no conscious slight was intended, but that’s the truth.

Anyway, here’s the link to the poll

After taking the poll you will be able to see the results to date.

Spoiler Alert: If you keep reading you will get the early returns based on the first 25 voters






McCain strongly favored, Democratic race tight

The first 9 Republicans responding to the Clarion Presidential Poll strongly favored John McCain over Rudy Giuliani by a 7-2 margin. None of the other four Republican candidates received any votes. On the Democratic side, there were 11 votes with Hillary Clinton edging Barack Obama 5- 4 . John Edwards received one vote and one Democrat was undecided.

Of five responders who said they were not enrolled in a party, two preferred Obama with Clinton and McCain getting one vote each. One of the unaffiliated voters was also undecided.

In the controversial match-up question, McCain was the only Republican who was at all competitive against either Clinton or Obama, although both Democrats were favored by the overall sample. Clinton bested McCain 14-11, while Obama was slightly stronger, winning 15-10. Mitt Romney was the next strongest Republican, but lost badly 20-5 against Clinton and 21-4 against Obama.

As far as issues, the war in Iraq and the economy were the two biggest concern, with over 70 per cent calling those issues “very important” in making their decision. The next most important issue was the personal character of the candidate which was cited by 57% as very important. The least important issues were illegal immigration and social issues which were each called very important by only 17 per cent.

Other issues volunteered included the Environment (by 4 people), Health Care (2), Controlling Lobbyists (2), and Social Security (2). The following issues were mentioned by one person each: Gun rights, Open Government, Poverty, Fair Trade and Human Rights.

For complete results click here. The poll will continue for at least another week.